Job is saved!

Click your avatar to
access saved jobs and applications

Barista/Cafe Supervisor
Piccadilly Market - Lincoln Park
444 West Fullerton Parkway, Chicago, IL
Piccadilly Market - Lincoln Park hiring Barista/Cafe Supervisor in Chicago, IL

Piccadilly Market - Lincoln Park hiring Barista/Cafe Supervisor in Chicago, IL

Barista/Cafe Supervisor

Piccadilly Market - Lincoln ParkMore Info

444 West Fullerton Parkway, Chicago, IL
Full Time • Hourly ($20.00 - $22.00) plus tips
Expires: Dec 20, 2026

Be an early applicant

Schedule
Days: Sunday, Monday, Tuesday, Friday, Saturday
Shifts: Early AM, Day
Weekends Required. Full availability preferred.

Required Years of Experience

2 years


Job Details

Piccadilly Market is a neighborhood market and cafe in Lincoln Park, with another location in Lincoln Square. It is part of a small Chicago hospitality company that also includes Piccadilly Pub and The Northman Beer & Cider Garden on the Riverwalk.


One Store, Three Businesses
Under one roof, we run a specialty cafe, a curated retail market and a wine & cocktail bar, with one team serving the same guests all day. A guest who grabs a latte at 8 a.m. may shop for a bottle of wine at noon and come back for happy hour.

Everyone here works across all three sides of the store, and this role sets that example for the cafe team.


The Barista/Cafe Supervisor runs our cafe counter day to day. You'll set the creative direction for the cafe program, lead recipe development, seasonal menus and specials, and run the barista team on shift.
You'll also own drink quality, opening, closing, inventory and food safety for the cafe. This is a hands-on role: you'll be on bar for most of your shift, setting the standard by example.

You'll start full time at Lincoln Park. After that, plan to spend one day a week at our Lincoln Square location, checking in with that team, their barista lead and management. With support from the rest of the team, you'll help guide the coffee menu across both locations.

What You Will Do
1. Lead the Cafe Program
- Oversee the creative direction of the cafe, including the drink menu, presentation and how the cafe fits the market.- Lead recipe development for signature and house drinks; write tested recipe specs the whole team can follow.
- Plan and roll out seasonal menu changes each season.
- Create rotating specials and limited-time drinks, including for holidays and neighborhood events.
- Cost out new recipes and set prices with the Store Manager to hit margin targets.
- Train the team on every new drink before it launches.
- Cross-train market associates on cafe basics (drip, espresso, pastry case, register) and help baristas learn the sales floor, so the whole team can cover all three sides of the store.
2. Lead the Team & Guest Experience
- Run the cafe floor: assign positions, set breaks and keep the line moving during rushes.
- Train new baristas on drinks, service standards and opening/closing procedures.
- Give in-the-moment coaching and flag performance issues to the Store Manager.
- Lead by example in everything you do: how you treat guests and teammates, cleaning standards, and going above and beyond in maintaining and improving guest interaction and service quality.
- Handle guest complaints, remakes and special requests.
- Know the market's grab-and-go and retail items well enough to suggest pairings.
3. Own Drink Quality & Cafe Standards
- Dial in espresso daily and keep recipes consistent across every barista.
- Taste-check drinks and correct issues on the spot.
- Keep the espresso machine, grinders and brewers clean and maintained; log and report repairs.
- Lead opening and closing procedures, including cleaning logs, temperature checks and shift close-out.
- Follow food safety rules for dairy, pastries and prepared items; keep the cafe ready for health inspections at all times.
- Run the POS, count drawers and follow posted refund and return policies at the register.
4. Run Inventory and Ordering
- Count and order coffee, milk, syrups, cups and cafe supplies on a set schedule.
- Rotate stock, track waste and keep par levels tight.
- Receive deliveries and check them against invoices.
5. Support the Lincoln Square Location
- Once you're settled at Lincoln Park, spend one day a week at Lincoln Square.
- Check in with the Lincoln Square team, their barista lead and management.
- Help guide the coffee menu across both locations, with support from the rest of the team.


What We are Looking For
  • 2+ years as a barista in a specialty or high-volume cafe, including at least 6 months as a lead, shift lead or supervisor.
  • Experience developing drink recipes, seasonal menus or specials.
  • Excellent espresso skills: dialing in, milk texturing and drink consistency.
  • Comfortable leading peers, giving direct feedback and handling unhappy guests calmly.
  • Food handler certificate & BASSET certification or able to get one within 30 days of hire.
  • Basic POS and cash handling; comfortable with counts and order sheets.
Nice to Have
  • Food service sanitation manager certification (ServSafe Manager or City of Chicago).
  • Experience ordering from roasters, dairy or bakery vendors.
  • Basic drink costing (cost per cup, margins).
  • Grocery, retail or prepared-foods experience.
Schedule & Physical Demands
  • Shifts start as early as 6:00 a.m.; weekends and holidays required.
  • On your feet for full shifts; frequent bending, reaching and repetitive motion.
  • Lift up to 50 lb (milk crates, deliveries).

Compensation Details

Compensation: Hourly ($20.00 - $22.00) plus tips

Benefits & Perks: Paid Time Off, Dining Discounts


Required Skills

Creativity in Menu Development

Leadership and team management

Customer Service Excellence

Problem Solving Skills

Attention to Detail

Time Management

Ability to Work Under Pressure

Effective Communication Skills

Training and Mentoring Abilities

Knowledge of Food Safety Regulations

Inventory Management

Adaptability to Different Work Environments

Collaboration With Cross Functional Teams

Read more


Other jobs you might be interested in

Assistant Restaurant Manager
The Staley
Full Time • Salary ($65k)
Pangea Restaurant Group
Chicago, IL • Casual Dining
Manager
Cozy Corner Restaurant and Pancake House
Full Time • Salary ($50k - $500k)
Cozy Corner Restaurant & Pancake House
Chicago, IL • Bakery / Patisserie
+1 Awards
Assistant Manager
theWit Hotel
Full Time • Salary ($55k - $60k)
Chicago, IL • Boutique Hotel
Assistant Manager
Matilda Restaurant
Full Time • Salary ($65k - $75k)
Exodo Hospitality Group
Chicago, IL • Bar / Lounge

Salads / Sandwiches / Soups, Coffee / Tea

Markets, Cafe

Part of Fountainhead Hospitality

Our goal is to connect food & beverage artisans directly with local residents, through a fun and vibrant shop that’s welcoming to all. We’re open day and night to serve the community, offering workspace, coffee, sandwiches, cheese, wine, specialty ice cream, flowers, fresh bread and much more! Most importantly, every member of our neighborhood shop is dedicated to serving our customers with sincere gratitude and hospitality.

Leadership
Emily Bonoyer

Human Resources Manager

Front of House Staff