Job is saved!

Click your avatar to
access saved jobs and applications

Counter Server
Petee's Café
505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA
Petee's Café hiring Counter Server in New York, NY

Petee's Café hiring Counter Server in New York, NY

Counter Server

Petee's CaféMore Info

505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, USA
Part Time • Hourly ($18.00) plus tips
Expired: Nov 16, 2026

Sorry, this job expired on Nov 16, 2026. Below are other jobs that may be of interest to you.

Required Years of Experience

0-1 years


Job Details

About us

Petee’s Pie Company makes what New York Magazine called “NYC’s Absolute Best Pie.” We’re hiring an energetic, friendly counter server for our Brooklyn café. You’ll be the face of Petee’s for the neighborhood: getting to know regulars, helping first-timers pick a slice, and keeping the café running smoothly from rush to close.

What you’ll do

  • Greet, guide, and serve customers at the counter
  • Ring up orders and take payments on our POS system
  • Assemble and bake pies
  • Keep the café clean, including dishes, sweeping, and mopping
  • Communicate clearly with teammates and managers during every shift

What we’re looking for

  • 1+ years of professional restaurant or café experience
  • A NYC Food Handler’s certificate, or you get one soon after you’re hired. This is required, and we cover the cost.
  • Availability for nights and weekends, including on and around holidays (Thanksgiving is our Super Bowl)
  • You keep your energy and stay organized under pressure, even late in a shift
  • You’re a team player who takes feedback well and adapts quickly
  • Able to carry 50 lbs up and down stairs
  • Espresso experience is a plus

Why work here

  • $18/hr base, with tips averaging about $7.41/hr this year
  • 401(k)
  • Vision and dental contributions
  • Non-slip shoe stipend
  • Paid food handler certification
  • Schedules posted two weeks in advance
  • $50 monthly employee credit, a free slice every shift, and a 40% employee discount
  • A small, close team at a beloved neighborhood café

Compensation Details

Compensation: Hourly ($18.00) plus tips

Benefits & Perks: Dental Insurance, Vision Insurance, 401k, Dining Discounts


Required Skills

Customer Service Skills

Time Management

Attention to Detail

Ability to work in a fast paced environment

Adaptability

Team Collaboration

Problem Solving Skills

Organizational Skills

Communication Skills

Ability to Handle Feedback

Multitasking

Work Ethic

Positive Attitude

Knowledge of food safety practices

Read more

View Job Description

Other jobs you might be interested in

Server
Friedmans Restaurant Group
Full Time • Hourly ($11.35) plus tips
Friedmans Restaurant Group
New York, NY • Restaurant Group
Prepared Foods Team Member (Deli Service Counter & Culinary Venues) - Part Time
Whole Foods Market
Part Time • Hourly ($18.25 - $25.40)
Whole Foods Market
Darien, CT • Specialty Grocer
Server
Yakiniku Great
Full/Part Time • Hourly ($11.35) plus tips
New York, NY • Fine Dining
Award
Server - Yoshoku
Waldorf Astoria New York
Full Time • Hourly ($17.81 - $21.24)
Hilton Hotels & Resorts
New York, NY • Luxury Hotel
Server
La Pecora Bianca - Bryant Park
Full/Part Time • Hourly ($17.00) plus tips
La Pecora Bianca
New York, NY • Upscale Casual
Waiter / Waitress
Rincon De España
Full Time • Hourly ($6.05) plus tips
Bayonne, NJ • Casual Dining
Server
PMac's Hospitality Group
Full Time • Hourly ($17.00) plus tips
PMAC's Hospitality Group
New York, NY • Restaurant Group
Seafood Team Member (Service Counter) - Part Time
Whole Foods Market
Part Time • Hourly ($17.00 - $25.40)
Whole Foods Market
Parsippany-Troy Hills, NJ • Specialty Grocer
+2 Awards
Kitchen Server
Clemente Bar
Full Time • Hourly ($17.00) plus tips
Daniel Humm Hospitality
New York, NY • Restaurant Group
Server
Nabila's
Full/Part Time • Hourly ($50.00 - $60.00)
Brooklyn, NY • Upscale Casual
Meat Team Member (Service Counter) - Full Time
Whole Foods Market
Full Time • Hourly ($18.75 - $25.40)
Whole Foods Market
Wall Township, NJ • Specialty Grocer
Server
DiWine
Full Time • Hourly ($11.50 - $12.00) plus tips
Queens, NY • Wine Bar
Prepared Foods Team Member (Deli Service Counter & Culinary Venues) - Full Time
Whole Foods Market
Full Time • Hourly ($17.50 - $25.40)
Whole Foods Market
Huntington Station, NY • Markets
Meat Team Member (Service Counter) - Part Time
Whole Foods Market - Tribeca
Part Time • Hourly ($18.00 - $25.40)
Whole Foods Market
New York, NY • Specialty Grocer
Front of House Staff
Her Name is Han
Full/Part Time • Hourly ($11.35) plus tips
HAND Hospitality
New York, NY • Casual Dining
+5 Awards
Front Server
César
Full Time • Hourly ($17.00 - $20.00) plus tips
New York, NY • Fine Dining
Front of House Lead
Burrito Bear
Full Time • Hourly ($16.50)
New York, NY • Quick Service
Server
Michael's of Brooklyn
Full Time • Hourly ($11.35) plus tips
Brooklyn, NY • Upscale Casual
Server
Opto Restaurant
Full Time • Hourly ($11.00) plus tips
New York, NY • Fine Dining
Server
Shalel
Full Time • Hourly ($11.35 - $13.35) plus tips
New York, NY • Bar / Lounge
Banquet Server
Noor Staffing Group, LLC - New York
Seasonal • Hourly ($23.00 - $25.00)
Noor Staffing Group
New York, NY • Recruiting Agency
+3 Awards
Server
The Clocktower
Full/Part Time • Hourly ($11.35) plus tips
STARR Restaurants
New York, NY • Upscale Casual
Wait Staff
Dear Strangers
Part Time • Hourly ($11.35) plus tips
New York, NY • Upscale Casual
Award
Server
ARIARI
Full/Part Time • Hourly ($17.00) plus tips
HAND Hospitality
New York, NY • Casual Dining

Desserts

Cafe, Bakery / Patisserie

Part of Petee's Pie Company

Named The Absolute Best Pie in New York City by New York Magazine, Petee's Pie Co serves a seasonal menu of freshly baked sweet and savory pies made with the best locally sourced ingredients. The charming cafe on Myrtle Ave is owned by second generation pie baker Petra "Petee" Paredez and her husband Robert. The couple opened Petee's together in early 2015 to much fanfare, and the company has received numerous accolades, including being named one of America's Legendary Pie Shops by USA Today. Petee's is consistently ranked as one of New York City's best pie shops in outlets such as Eater, Gothamist, Thrillist, Timeout NY and more.